First Class Roofing white Logo

Comprehensive Guide to Siding Choices for Your Home

Table of Contents

When it comes to your home’s exterior, few choices have as significant an impact as the type of siding you select. Your siding not only serves as a protective barrier but also greatly influences your home’s curb appeal and value. In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into four common siding options: Vinyl, Wood, Metal, and Fiber Cement. We’ll explore their durability, cost, R-values, and other essential factors to help you make an informed decision.

Comparing Siding Types

Before we dive into the specifics of each siding type, let’s take a quick overview of their key characteristics.

Vinyl Siding

Best for: Affordable siding that closely resembles wood.

Overview: Vinyl siding emerged as a low-cost, low-maintenance alternative to traditional wood and has become a popular choice in the United States. It is available in various styles, colors, and textures, making it a versatile option for homeowners.

Installation: Vinyl is often used as a retrofit siding, placed over old wood siding with fiber panels for added insulation. Proper installation is crucial to prevent warping or buckling.

Cost: Vinyl siding is considered the most budget-friendly option, with national average installation costs ranging from $3 to $8 per square foot.


  • Affordable
  • Durable, with some products offering warranties up to 50 years
  • Never requires repainting
  • Quick professional installation


  • Prone to cracking in cold weather
  • Limited repair options for damaged planks
  • Difficulty in finding repair materials
  • Susceptible to fire and heat damage

Wood Siding

Best for: Achieving a natural wood finish.

Overview: Wood siding, available in lap siding planks, boards, or siding panels, offers a timeless and attractive option. It is especially suitable when you desire an authentic look for your home.

Installation: Installing wood siding involves insulated sheathing, weatherproofing, and meticulous nailing of planks or shakes. While not overly complicated, it can be time-consuming.

Cost: Wood siding costs vary widely, with average installation costs ranging from $3 to $10 per square foot, depending on wood species and style.


  • Accepts various stains and paint finishes
  • Provides an authentic, luxurious look
  • Easy to change appearance by repainting
  • Installation requires basic carpentry skills


  • Requires regular maintenance, including repainting or restaining
  • Prone to moisture damage
  • Relatively expensive
  • Highly flammable, not suitable for wildfire-prone regions

Metal Siding: Aluminum and Steel

Best for: Affordable and durable siding.

Overview: Metal siding, whether aluminum or steel, gained popularity in response to the high maintenance needs of wood siding. It offers a low-maintenance alternative with a similar appearance to wood.

Installation: Metal siding is often applied as “retrofit” siding, placed over existing wood siding with fiber panels for insulation.

Cost: Uncoated steel and aluminum have moderate costs, averaging $3 to $6 per square foot for aluminum and $4 to $8 per square foot for steel.


  • Low-maintenance
  • Multiple style options available
  • Very durable, with some products offering warranties up to 35 years
  • Resists heat and fire


  • Prone to dents
  • Older products may experience fading or chalking of finishes
  • Noise during hail or rain storms
  • Repainting requires careful preparation

Fiber Cement Siding

Best for: Premium appearance with low maintenance needs.

Overview: Fiber cement siding, made from Portland cement and natural cellulose wood fibers, offers a premium appearance similar to wood. It is highly durable and requires minimal maintenance.

Installation: Fiber cement siding is installed similarly to wood siding, with cutting and nailing to framing members over insulation and house wrap.

Cost: Fiber cement is moderately expensive, with a national average cost of about $10 per square foot, installed.


  • Very long-lasting, often with 50-year warranties
  • Resists moisture damage and insects
  • Unaffected by heat and flame


  • Moderately expensive
  • Heavy material, challenging for DIY installation
  • Eventually requires repainting

Choosing a Siding Material

The right siding material for your home depends on factors like your budget, DIY aspirations, and your willingness to maintain it. Here are some recommendations:

  • Natural Wood Siding: Ideal for achieving an authentic, genuine look. Best suited for historical restorations but requires regular maintenance.
  • Fiber Cement Siding: Offers a wood-like appearance with minimal maintenance needs. A great choice for those who want the aesthetics of wood without the upkeep.
  • Metal Siding: An affordable and durable option suitable for various climates. Aluminum is budget-friendly, while steel offers enhanced durability.

In conclusion, the choice of siding material for your home should align with your priorities and budget. Each option has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, so carefully consider your needs before making a decision. Remember that quality installation is essential to maximize the lifespan and performance of your chosen siding material.